More homes are selling at a loss. What does that mean for investors?
Cotality’s latest Pain & Gain report found that 15.8% of homes sold nationwide went for less than their owners paid, rising to 25.5% in Auckland. In this week’s Media Links, Matt explains how inflation and ownership costs can turn an apparent gain into a real loss. He looks at what that means for investors who’ve relied on capital growth, where buyers may have more room to negotiate, and whether rising net migration could support rental demand.

written by Matt Ball
16 November 2026
This week in 60 seconds
- More sellers are taking a loss. Nationwide, 15.8% of properties sold for less than their purchase price last quarter. In Auckland it was 25.5%, compared with 5.5% in Queenstown.
- A $125,000 paper gain can hide a real loss. One home bought for $1.6 million in 2019 sold for $1.725 million this year. After allowing for inflation and estimated selling costs, Matt puts the real loss at around $400,000.
- The deal needs to stack up from day one. With capital growth harder to count on, rental income and ongoing costs matter more. A wider choice of listings can also give buyers time to do their homework and room to negotiate in some areas.
- The proposed capital gains tax raises a question. Matt asks what happens when a sale shows a taxable gain on paper even though the owner has lost money in inflation-adjusted terms.
- Net migration is picking up. New Zealand recorded a net gain of 22,600 people in the year to September 2026, up 12,700 on the previous year. That could support rental demand, particularly in Auckland.
This week's stories in detail
Advocacy in Action: Media
Cotality’s Pain & Gain report showed more loss-making sales last quarter than in any time since Q3 in 2021. Nationwide, 15.8% of properties were sold for a nominal loss. In Auckland, that number was 25.5%! Over a quarter of properties sold for less than the owner paid for them. Even in Queenstown, our most resilient housing market, 5.5% of people sold for a loss.
Newstalk ZB asked me to come on and discuss the numbers. The point I made, which I think is really important to consider, is that these are nominal profit and loss number. They don’t take into account the costs associated with buying and selling a property. They don’t factor in anything people spend on repairs, maintenance or upgrades. They don’t include holding costs, like rates, insurance or mortgage interest.
Most of all, they don’t include inflation, which can be the biggest effect. That’s included in this Herald article, in which I gave the following example. I looked up a random property near me which had sold recently, so see what the effect of inflation had been.
The first place I found was a home brought in 2019 for $1.6 million and sold earlier this year for $1.725m. It would show up as having made a $125k profit in the Pain & Gain report. Sale costs are likely to be around $30k, so we’re already under $100k profit taking that into account. Inflation is the big one.
Using the Reserve Bank’s inflation calculator, we can see that something bought for $1.6 million in 2019 would cost over $2.1 million today. So selling for $1,725 million is well short. I would estimate that property made a real loss of more like $400,000, definitely not a profit.
What are the implications of this?
Well, there is the general implication for owner occupiers that your home can no longer be treated like an ATM. This is something we’ve seen time and time again, when the housing market jumps up, it makes people feel richer, and so they spend, sometimes funded by increased borrowing on their homes. Assuming the nascent economic recovery continues next year, this will be the first time in I don’t know how long that we’ve had an economic recovery that’s not housing led. That’s actually quite an achievement.
There is the impact on investors, who can no longer rely on capital growth from their portfolios. This will have many outcomes, from people who are near retirement selling up now, rather than wait to get a bit more capital gain, all the way to people not entering the business because the numbers don’t add up. I think it will definitely have an impact on the number of people getting into property investing.
It will impact on the type of property investing people do. If short term rentals (e.g. holiday lets) are more lucrative, then more people may switch to that. It will make flipping harder. Flipping in the sense of buying, do up and sell. Trading is pretty much dead in most places, unless you can get a real bargain.
It makes it even more urgent for politicians to let go of the idea that property investing is a lucrative, speculative activity. If Labour manages to pull off a deal to take power and introduces their special CGT, I think it will kill the rental sector stone dead. Why on earth would you bother if you can make a loss and still get taxed on it.
Take the example above. Having made a paper profit of $125,000, you’d get a tax bill of $35,000! Golly gosh, that’s rough (or stronger words to that effect). It’s an absolute nightmare of a policy and I could see our housing and rental market going the same way as Australia or the UK as a result.
What about the positives? Yes, there are some. First off, cheaper housing means you can get a better deal on a property, and you can likely haggle over the price in some parts of the country. Thanks to the high supply of houses for sale, you’ll have more time to do due diligence and make sure the numbers work.
Second, the situation means there’s more need for fiscal discipline, you can’t afford to just buy, and hope capital gain will cover any mistakes. This sort of discipline isn’t a bad thing, we should all do it all the time, and now we’ll all be almost forced to.
Finally, I can see a situation emerging where enough people sell out of the rental market, particularly of properties that are perhaps not ideal rentals. That will reduce supply, which will at some point lead to supply and demand coming into balance in most areas. Perhaps we might even see rent increases!
On a related note, migration numbers are trending up.
Stats NZ figures show a net migration gain of 22,600 in the September 2026 year, up 12,700 on the previous year. Migrant arrivals rose 7% to 136,100, while departures fell 3% to 113,500.
As we all know, migration is good for rental demand, and given Auckland usually takes the highest number of newcomers, this shift could be good for that market.
So there you have it. We are living through a significant shift in how our housing market works, with some positives and some difficulties. It will affect investors and owner-occupiers alike and could completely change our national mindset around housing.
Member Benefits That Make a Difference
Local Community
Strong Advocacy
Education Access
Exclusive Discounts
Weekly Media Updates
Members-Only Resources
Current Projects
Related Posts
Weekly Media Links Mon 9 Nov 2026
Weekly Media LinksThe votes are in, but New Zealand's next government is far from settled. With Chris Bishop out of Parliament, a new...
Look past the headlines: lessons for long-term investors from PMG
Weekly Media Links Mon 2 Nov November 2026
Weekly Media LinksWith election day just around the corner, Labour has finally released its rental housing policy, confirming plans to...
Weekly Media Links Tues 27 October 2026
Weekly Media LinksIt’s a short week, but there’s still plenty happening. Voting is underway, another OCR rise looks likely, and global...
Weekly Media Links Mon 19 October 2026
Weekly Media LinksIt’s been a busy week in housing politics, with ACT making a surprise promise to scrap rental loss ring-fencing and...
ACT adopts NZPIF ring-fencing proposal and goes further: a major advocacy win
ACT has announced it will campaign to remove rental loss ring-fencing for all residential rental properties, going further than the new-build...
As featured on






